Georgia bishop asks pardons board to spare inmate’s life

By Don Plummer
Posted Jan 23, 2015

[Episcopal Diocese of Atlanta] Bishop Rob Wright Jan. 26 sent a letter to the chair and members of Georgia’s Board of Pardons and Paroles asking them to spare the life of an intellectually disabled death-row inmate. Warren Lee Hill is scheduled to be executed Jan. 27.

       Warren Hill

Warren Hill

Hill, whose intellectual disability has been twice confirmed by lower courts, had his final appeal to the State Supreme Court denied Jan. 20. The Board of Pardons and Paroles, which meets Jan. 26, provides Hill with a last opportunity for avoiding the death penalty unless the U.S. Supreme Court intervenes.

In his letter Wright made a biblical argument against executing Hill. “While many people support capital punishment, Holy Scripture clearly shows Jesus never taught that we should murder a human being, no matter how heinous the crime.”

He told the board that he was greatly encouraged in July 2014 when they commuted the death sentence to life without parole in the case of Tommy Lee Waldrip.

“Your decision was a victory for morality and human dignity and I praise you for your action. Today I urge you to again take the courageous path and spare the life of Mr. Hill,” he said.

Since 1984, Georgia has executed 56 people, an average of two per year. However, in the past year Georgia has increased the frequency of executions with six scheduled executions.

Since 1954, The Episcopal Church has called repeatedly for an end to executions. Wright said in a letter to more than 200 clergy in his diocese that he hopes they will express concern to state officials — and physically witness their opposition to the death penalty. “As we all know, capital punishment can never bring an end to killing,” he said.

This is not the first time Wright has called an end to Georgia executions. In December, he wrote a letter to Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal urging a halt to the practice. At that time Robert Wayne Holsey was facing execution. Holsey was executed Dec. 9 for the murder of Baldwin County sheriff’s deputy Will Robinson.

On Jan. 13 the state also executed Andrew Howard Brannan, a decorated war veteran who suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, according to court records. Brannan was put to death for the 1998 murder of 22-year-old Laurens County Sheriff’s Deputy Kyle Wayne Dinkheller.

Georgia is the only state to require evidence of intellectual disability to be proved beyond a reasonable doubt. All other states use a less-strict standard of proof.

In a New York Times editorial published Jan. 23, the editors said “Mr. Hill’s case is a catalog of everything that is wrong with the death penalty.”

Vigils protesting the death penalty are planned for outside Georgia’s death-row prison and in Atlanta and 10 other locations throughout Georgia, according to Georgians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty website.


Comments (3)

  1. Dudley Sharp says:

    The evidence is overwhelming that HILL WAS NOT MENTALLY DISABLED

    Hill never presented any mental disability claim in his two murder trials, and it was not used until five years AFTER his death sentence. The claims of mental disability were destroyed.

    Both Hill’s job record and his military history lay waste to the mentally disabled claims.

  2. Stephen Deutermann says:

    This last, failed appeal is symptomatic of the problems a state justice system has administering capital punishment. At one time in my life I believed there were justifications for the death penalty. My experience in Kairos prison ministry began to change that, and my study of the issue over the past several decades has affirmed to me that the death penalty is beyond mankind’s ability. Our society’s attempts to “civilize” the procedures used to stop a beating heart by strapping to a gurney and injecting fatal dosages of numbing agents and poison is an indicator that we know ending a life is not a right we hold. The rest of a convicts life in a cage is adequate punishment, perhaps even worse than being put to sleep by the state. Let the gift of life be awarded and revoked by God alone.

    1. Richard McClellan says:

      Couldn’t have said it any better. I feel the same way about abortion as well. ALL life, from natural conception until natural death, is precious in God’s eyes.

Comments are closed.