VIRGINIA: ‘Continuing congregations’ turn focus to future

By Emily Cherry
Posted May 30, 2012

Church of the Epiphany Episcopal welcomes the community to worship. Photo/Frances Caldwell

[Episcopal News Service] The past weeks have been a time of transition for the Diocese of Virginia. Congregations that have worshiped away from their home churches for more than five years have made joyful homecomings to their church buildings. The entire diocese has joined in celebrating these returns, all while entering into a discernment process to help these congregations make plans for the future.

The recent returns and celebrations have been a longtime coming for the four “continuing congregations” that have worshipped in temporary spaces while the diocese and breakaway congregations that had joined the Convocation of Anglican Churches in North America fought over rights to diocese-owned properties in the courts. The breakaway congregations occupied the church buildings throughout the court proceedings.

In all, seven church properties (and a number of additional buildings and land parcels) have been returned to the Diocese of Virginia following the near conclusion of a five-year legal dispute. Each has a different story to tell, and telling these stories is a key part of a diocesan initiative known as “Dayspring,” an effort to discern the work of the Holy Spirit with graciousness and patience as the diocese explores how best to use resources and properties for the ministry of the church.

As the continuing congregations have begun discerning their way forward, each has realized that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to a new beginning.

Members of Church of the Epiphany in Fairfax returned home on May 6, after worshiping in a local school. While making that transition, they’re also welcoming a new interim vicar and are turning to social media and marketing to increase their visibility in the community.

It’s been a time of challenge, but since returning home the congregation has tripled Sunday attendance and doubled its membership from 25 to 50 members.

The congregation also has benefitted from what the Rev. Jennifer McKenzie, interim vicar, calls the “Blessing-a-Day Club.” A slew of blessings that “seem to fall out of the sky,” she said, have landed on Epiphany’s doorstep, including volunteer musical groups for Sunday worship, pro-bono graphic design services, and more.

“The biggest challenge right now for us is building the staff infrastructure that we need to support this growth, so that as this growth continues, we don’t let people slip through the cracks and lose people,” said McKenzie.

The congregation’s hopes for the future are high. It’s launching a new branding- and direct-mail effort to raise the church’s image and presence in the community; hosting community groups, from the Boy Scouts to an Irish dance group; and participating in a local festival. And it’s rolling out the welcome mat. “Our big thing here is, ‘All are welcome,’ said McKenzie. “And we really mean that. When people walk in the door, we want them to know that there is a place for them.”

The Rt. Rev. Ted Gulick, assistant bishop in Virginia, and the Rev. Kate Chipps, priest-in-charge of St. Margaret’s, Woodbridge, celebrate a baptism with the continuing congregation. Photo/Courtesy St. Margaret’s, Woodbridge

The continuing congregation of St. Margaret’s in Woodbridge, meanwhile, hasn’t made an official “move.” Although the original St. Margaret’s church property was returned to the diocese earlier this spring, the congregation continues to worship in its “temporary” worship space, which it shares with three other denominations. Members of the congregation are joining together to discuss what shape their physical church will take in the years to come. Meanwhile, they’re saying goodbye to the Rev. Kate Chipps, priest-in-charge, who has led them through this difficult process. Chipps will retire in July.

St. Margaret’s vestry is leading the congregation through this time of transition, gathering input from members on the best possible worship space to meet their needs, and meeting with the Dayspring teams to discern a way to move the congregation out of “reaction mode” into “planning mode,” explained Eleana Boyer, senior warden.

“The spirit of the church is moving more toward a positive direction,” added Boyer. That doesn’t mean that they aren’t facing challenges, including how to grow their congregation and how to financially support their ministries. But they’re meeting those challenges head-on. “Once we get through this transition and change, you’ll see us really shine,” said Boyer. “We are a faithful people. We have come this far by faith, and we are moving forward in faith.”

Members of St. Stephen’s in Heathsville returned to their church building on Palm Sunday and the congregation is as active as ever. Members are busy planning their community strawberry festival and the annual spring barbecue and bluegrass event. Read more about their story here.

And then there’s the Falls Church, a congregation that continued to grow while worshipping in a temporary space, and where a large number of members have just “returned” to a church building where they’ve never worshipped before.

“It’s just really exciting to see how things are falling into place,” said the Rev. Cathy Tibbetts, priest-in-charge.

On the congregation’s first evening back in its worship space, members opened the doors to the building, inviting families to come and explore the church grounds. “We wanted them to have the opportunity to explore the blessings that God has bestowed on us,” said Tibbetts.

The congregation is looking at growing its clergy staff, including calling a “planter-builder” to oversee the church’s growth process.

A community focus is a large part of the Falls Church Episcopal DNA, according to Mike Lockaby, the senior warden.

“I think that being involved in the community is going to draw in people who previously did not feel welcome, or previously were un-churched,” he said. So the congregation focuses on “being more open to our community and more positive toward our community and more involved in what’s local.”

In addition, they’re looking inward by establishing small group ministries, in which 10-to-16 parishioners will gather for fellowship and/or Christian formation. The congregation also has instituted a “partnership ministry,” which gives newcomers a contact person who is familiar with the church’s culture and spirit and who can determine the best way to welcome that person. “The message that we have been stressing and that we wish to continue to stress is, ‘We welcome you,’ and there’s no asterisk to that,” said Lockaby.

The Falls Church Anglican is the only one out of the seven properties returned to the Diocese that continues to pursue its appeal. The diocese has made settlement negotiations with the other six congregations involved in the litigation. In these cases, the Convocation of Anglicans in North America congregations agreed to return church property and Episcopal funds, and to withdraw their appeals.

In addition to the church buildings belonging to the four continuing congregations, three additional church properties have been returned to the diocese as a result of the litigation. These churches previously did not have continuing Episcopal congregations associated with them. The diocese already has reinstated Episcopal worship services at St. Paul’s in Haymarket; and the property of Church of the Apostles, Fairfax, also has been returned to diocesan ownership. The diocese has arranged a yearlong lease with the Anglican congregation of Truro Church, Fairfax, and both parties have agreed to enter into a “covenant of mutual charity and respect,” a piece of the agreement which the Rt. Rev. Shannon S. Johnston, bishop of Virginia, describes as “an opening for a transformative witness to many across the worldwide Anglican Communion.”

Coordinating these efforts amidst unique circumstances is no small task. And that’s where Dayspring comes in. The Dayspring initiative – so named for the poetic, biblical term that translates to “new dawn,” brings together leaders from across the Diocese of Virginia to plan, vision and strategize about the properties returning to the diocese, and how best to put them to use for the mission of the Episcopal Church in Virginia. Johnston is at the head of the effort, which also is guided by the Rev. Canon Susan Goff, bishop suffragan-elect, and Henry D.W. Burt, secretary of the diocese.

“It is heartening to consider how the Diocese of Virginia is responding to the staggering richness of the possibilities before us,” said Burt in a recent letter to the diocese. “Each of the continuing congregations remains profoundly committed to its mission and ministry. They are experiencing significant growth, and Dayspring teams are considering a number of transformational mission efforts at churches where no continuing congregation exists. There is tremendous energy and a gracious spirit ever present in this work.”

— Emily Cherry is the communications officer for the Diocese of Virginia.

Comments (9)

  1. Bob Hansel says:

    Seems to me that this was such an inevitable outcome, isn’t it a shame all the time, expense, and personal distress had to be lived-through? Although the ‘Anglican” adherents clearly believed in what they were doing, they have caused the loss of countless hours and thousands of dollars that would better have gone into productive ministry. Our intramural squabbling over theological niceties is just too expensive a pastime for the Church to indulge in.

    1. Doug Desper says:

      Hi Bob,
      In comparing ministries of the churches, no one can even touch the Falls Church (Anglican). Their evidence of commitment to productive ministry is on their website, and it’s undeniably awesome, comprehensive, holistic, local-regional-worldwide, fully funded, and well-attended. Now, we shall see what the Falls Church (Episcopal) will do.

  2. Pegram Johnson III says:

    Well, I wouldn’t call ordination of women and embracing all of God’s children “theological niceties,” nay rather, they are theological necessities.

    1. Doug Desper says:

      Hi Pegram,
      The thousands who are associated with the departing congregations to become ACNA are not led by a few loud voices who object to women’s ordination as the main issue. The issue at hand for their dissent was and is the therological revisionism that plagues our Church. One can simply turn to the Easter Message by the PB and see what is missing: the name of Jesus Christ, His victory over death, and our hope of resurrection with Him. The Church’s high holy day was instead reduced to ruminations over “green” theology with no mention at all of Jesus Christ. Thankfully enough, there are still a lot of Episcopalians who have a problem with that revisionism. Those who have left and are leaving have not done so over “theological niceties”.

  3. James Dirlam says:

    We have to peacefully embrace the opposition to discern our way forward. There is no reconciliation without conflict. Ordaining women and embracing all of God’s children are the ways to move forward in our mission to reconcile all with Christ. The litigation was the means to do this. We ought not resent the challenge. It is part of the work of the Church.

  4. michael Neal says:

    And TEC continues its slippery slope……………………….. it won’t be long before the TEC churches are sold to the highest bidder because no one will go…………..TEC and the CoE need to wake up…………….while 70% of the Anglican Communion have revival, they continue the slow death, oh well , Jerusalem or Alexandria look good to be the NEW Canterbury…………..

  5. Steven Long says:

    Michael Neal is spot on. Most of the properties associated with returning congregations are in danger of or have been foreclosed as the smaller congregations don’t have the resources to pay debt and associated expenses. One facility was sold in a fire sale (after the departing congregation had offered to pay a much higher amount) and is being converted into a mosque. Where’s the victory in this? If the TEC was a public company, there would be countless lawsuits over such gross negligence.

    1. Doug Desper says:


      A few bloggers have opined about what would happen if the New York Attorney General ever became motivated to examine the books of our Church. One wonders how that would fare considering that our foreign and domestic missionary society has turned more resources into lawsuits and forced cohesion than into…missions. Very murky disclosure these days.

  6. John Pollock says:

    What a wonderful article! I am the rector of St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church in Morehead City, North Carolina. A continuing Episcopal parish which went though a departure in 2000. Since reclaiming our buildings in 2003, we have not only survived, but have thrived in the work of the Holy Spirit. The evidence of the Risen Christ working among us and in us is seen in the dramatic growth in membership, outreach and Christian Formation. God blessing these continuing congregations. They are signs of resurrection to all.

Comments are closed.